When you turn to a medical professional to treat an injury or illness or perform a medical procedure, you expect to receive a reasonable and widely acceptable standard of care. Unfortunately, that doesn’t always happen.
Medical malpractice is a serious issue that happens with alarming frequency in the U.S. It involves professional negligence in medical settings that results in avoidable health complications, financial losses, and other forms of harm.
One of the most common types of negligence for which medical professionals are found liable is the failure to monitor patients properly. Read on to learn more about what this means and what evidence is required to pursue a medical malpractice claim on this basis.
What Does “Failure to Monitor a Patient” Mean?
Failure to monitor a patient is a form of medical negligence that occurs when a healthcare provider doesn’t adequately observe, document, or respond to a patient’s condition and/or changes in a patient’s condition as that condition progresses.
In most cases, these errors aren’t deliberate. Instead, they’re usually the result of understaffing, which, sadly, impacts the majority of hospitals and clinics in the country. Patients exposed to nurse understaffing have higher mortality rates than those in well-staffed facilities, and the length of their stay is typically greater.
Failure to monitor patients can also stem from alarm fatigue. This phenomenon occurs when hospital staff become desensitized to alarms on medical devices because of how frequently they’re exposed to them.
As you might imagine, this type of medical negligence can have catastrophic consequences. Patients can experience life-threatening symptoms, including respiratory distress, or they could be left vulnerable to severe infections if the earliest symptoms aren’t detected immediately.
Proving a Failure-to-Monitor Claim
If you’ve suffered harm due to a care provider’s negligence, you might be thinking about filing a medical malpractice claim. However, these legal actions are different from other personal injury claims, as you must satisfy the reasonable person standard.
For your claim to succeed, you must prove that another care provider in the same field wouldn’t have made the same mistake that caused your injuries. This requires gathering a substantial amount of evidence to show that a duty of care existed and that there was a breach of the expected standard of care.
You must then demonstrate causation, which means that the provider’s conduct directly led to your injuries. Lastly, you’ll need to show that you’ve incurred actual losses for which you can be compensated. If a provider breached their duty of care, but you didn’t suffer a compensable injury, you won’t qualify to bring a claim.
Solid evidence is the cornerstone of a medical malpractice claim. Here are the most effective types to concentrate on.
| Evidence | What It May Show | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Medical Records | Vital signs, nursing observations, medications, changes in condition, and gaps in monitoring | Helps establish what care was provided and whether warning signs were documented or missed |
| Electronic Health Record Audit Logs | When providers accessed or updated a patient’s electronic records | May help establish whether and when a patient’s information was reviewed |
| Monitor & Alarm Records | When alarms sounded, how long they continued, and how staff responded | Can help demonstrate that warning signs occurred without an appropriate or timely response |
| Eyewitness Statements | Observations from patients, family members, visitors, or staff | Can provide additional context about delays, missed checks, ignored alarms, or facility practices |
| Expert Testimony | What a reasonably careful provider in the same field would have done | Helps establish the applicable standard of care and whether the provider’s conduct fell below it |
| Evidence of Injury & Losses | Additional treatment, medical expenses, lost income, or other harm | Helps connect the alleged negligence to actual damages suffered by the patient |
Complete Medical Records
One of the first and most important types of evidence you’ll gather is your medical records, including nursing charts and medication-administration records. Your lawyer will need to see these documents to understand your condition.
It will also be helpful to perform an electronic health records audit. That way, you can get a better sense of how often your doctor or nurses accessed your records, which could be essential for demonstrating that staff didn’t check on you as often as they should have.
Alarm Records
Monitor logs and alarms can offer clear evidence of negligence. The data downloaded from various medical devices can prove that alarms sounded, but no one took them seriously or actively turned them off.
Eyewitness Statements
Additionally, you can rely on eyewitnesses, whose testimony can paint a clear picture of what occurred.
Eyewitnesses don’t need to have been present at the time of the incident. Rather, they can speak about the moments leading up to it. If the facility has a workplace culture that encourages staff members to ignore alarms, for example, you might have an easier time proving that you received substandard care.
Expert Testimony
Testimony from medical professionals can be tremendously helpful in these cases. Although California doesn’t require an affidavit of merit, you’ll still need to obtain statements from expert witnesses to establish that the defendant failed to meet the standard of care expected in their field or specialty.
Entrust Your Case to an Experienced Medical Malpractice Attorney
Being hurt by someone who was supposed to help you can be devastating. You might end up with worsening illnesses or injuries, along with major medical expenses. If your losses are tied to a medical provider’s failure to monitor patients correctly or meet the medical standard of care, you may be eligible to pursue a medical malpractice claim. Understanding liability in these situations can be complex, particularly when evaluating whether a provider’s actions or omissions contributed to your injuries.
Attorney Bradley I. Kramer, M.D., Esq., is uniquely qualified to offer comprehensive guidance and representation in malpractice cases. As both an attorney and medical doctor, he understands the medical and legal issues that can arise in malpractice lawsuits. Contact our team today to set up a free, no-obligation consultation and learn more about your rights.
