What Leads to Failed Surgeries and Surgical Errors?

BIKLaw Medical Malpractice Lawyer > Surgical Errors > What Leads to Failed Surgeries and Surgical Errors?
Countless patients worldwide experience surgical errors each year. These errors can range from minor mistakes to catastrophic events with life-threatening consequences.

Empowering yourself with knowledge is crucial. By understanding the common causes of surgical errors, you can become a more informed and proactive patient, advocating for your safety throughout the surgical process.

Understanding Surgical Errors: Protecting Yourself During Surgery

Surgical errors are a serious concern, impacting millions of patients globally each year. This section will equip you with essential knowledge about these errors and how they can impact patients.

What are Surgical Errors?

A surgical error occurs when an unintended mistake happens during an operation, deviating from the accepted standard of care and causing harm to the patient. These errors can be classified into two main categories:

  1. Commission Errors: Performing an action that shouldn’t be done, like operating on the wrong body part or leaving a surgical instrument inside the patient.
  2. Omission Errors: Failing to take a necessary step during surgery, such as not administering the correct anesthesia or neglecting to sterilize equipment properly.

Common Types of Surgical Errors

Type of Error Description Example
Wrong-Site Surgery Operating on the incorrect body part, side of the body (left vs right), or performing an unintended procedure. Operating on the right instead of the left knee due to miscommunication or incorrect marking.
Anesthesia Errors Mistakes related to administering anesthesia, including incorrect dosage, allergic reactions, or inadequate monitoring. Administering an incorrect dosage of anesthesia leads to complications such as awareness during surgery or respiratory depression.
Surgical Instrument Errors Leaving surgical instruments or foreign objects unintentionally inside the patient’s body. Leaving a sponge or surgical instrument inside the patient’s abdomen after surgery.
Sewing or Stapling Errors Incorrect suturing or stapling techniques can cause internal bleeding or damage to organs. Suturing a blood vessel shut unintentionally during surgery that leads to internal bleeding.
Nerve Damage Unintentional nerve injury during surgery leads to numbness, weakness, or chronic pain. Damaging a nerve in the arm during surgery, resulting in permanent numbness and weakness in the hand.

While the exact number of surgical errors is difficult to determine, studies suggest they are more common than you might think. These errors can have a significant impact on patients, including each of the following:

  • Physical Injuries: Surgical errors can result in additional surgeries to correct the mistake, increased risk of infection, and potential for long-term disabilities.
  • Emotional Trauma: The experience of a surgical error can be emotionally devastating, causing anxiety, depression, and a loss of trust in the medical system.
  • Financial Burden: Additional surgeries, extended hospital stays, and rehabilitation costs can significantly burden patients and their families.

By understanding the types and prevalence of surgical errors, you can become a more informed and engaged patient, advocating for your safety throughout the surgical process.

The following sections will explore ways to minimize risks and maximize your well-being.

Why Surgeries Sometimes Fail

Surgical errors can arise from a complex interplay of factors, often called the “troubled triangle.” Understanding these factors empowers you to advocate for safety throughout the surgical process.

Human Factors

  • Surgeon Fatigue and Burnout: Exhausted surgeons are more prone to errors in judgment and may lack the focus and stamina required for complex procedures.
  • Inexperience or Lack of Skill: While all surgeons undergo a certain required level of training, entrusting a critical procedure to a surgeon who lacks sufficient experience or hasn’t honed their skills in that area can increase the risk of complications.
  • Miscommunication Among Surgical Team Members: Clear and concise communication is vital in the operating room. Breakdowns in communication, such as unclear instructions or misunderstandings between the surgeon, anesthesiologist, and nurses, can lead to errors.

Systemic Issues

Meticulous planning is essential for a successful surgery. Rushing into surgery without thorough planning, including reviewing imaging scans and a detailed understanding of the patient’s medical history, can increase the risk of errors.

Surgical equipment needs to be in pristine and sterile condition. Outdated or malfunctioning, or improperly sterilized equipment can compromise the surgeon’s ability to perform the procedure precisely.

Incomplete or inaccurate medical records can lead to unforeseen complications during surgery. Ensuring that your medical records are up-to-date and all relevant information is communicated to the surgical team is critical in advance of surgery.

Environmental Factors

  • Distractions in the Operating Room: The operating room should be a sterile and focused environment. Unnecessary distractions, such as excessive noise or interruptions, can disrupt the surgical team’s concentration and raise the risk of errors.
  • High Patient Turnover and Pressure to Perform Quickly: Hospitals with a high volume of surgeries may create pressure to rush through procedures. This can compromise patient safety and increase the likelihood of errors.
  • Inadequate Staffing and Support: An adequately staffed surgical team with experienced nurses and technicians is necessary for a smooth operation. Understaffing can lead to overworked personnel and a higher risk of mistakes.

By being aware of these potential trouble spots, you can become a more informed patient and ask questions about your surgeon’s experience, the hospital’s safety record, and the overall plan for your surgery.

Specific Types of Surgical Errors and How to Minimize Risks

While all surgeries carry some inherent risk, understanding specific types of surgical errors can empower you to ask informed questions and advocate for your safety. Here’s a closer look at some common errors and potential preventative measures:

1. Wrong-Site Surgery

Operating on the incorrect body part, side of the body (left vs right), or performing an unintended procedure. This is a serious error with potentially devastating consequences.


  • Miscommunication: Breakdown in communication among healthcare professionals regarding the surgical site.
  • Incorrect Marking: Failure to properly mark the surgical site on the patient’s body.
  • Similar-Appearing Anatomy: In rare cases, anatomical similarities can lead to confusion during surgery.

Prevention Strategies:

Strategy Description
“Time Out” Procedure Hospitals implement a protocol before surgery to verify the correct patient, procedure, and surgical site.
Double-Checking Surgeons and nurses independently verify the surgical site before making an incision.
Patient Participation Actively confirm the planned surgery with your doctor and nurses before the procedure.

2. Anesthesia Errors

Mistakes related to administering anesthesia include incorrect dosage, allergic reactions, or inadequate monitoring.

Types of Errors and Consequences:

  • Incorrect Dosage: An overdose can lead to respiratory depression or cardiac arrest, while an overdose may cause the patient to awaken during surgery.
  • Allergic Reactions: Failure to identify allergies or improper medication administration can lead to life-threatening allergic reactions.
  • Inadequate Monitoring: Insufficient monitoring of vital signs during surgery can delay the detection of complications.

Prevention Strategies:

Strategy Description
Pre-Anesthetic Evaluation A thorough evaluation by an anesthesiologist to identify any potential risks or allergies.
Advanced Monitoring Equipment Utilizing advanced monitoring equipment to track vital signs and ensure patient safety throughout surgery.
Experienced Anesthesiologists Ensuring the anesthesia is administered by a qualified and experienced professional.

3. Retained Surgical Items

Surgical instruments or other objects unintentionally left behind inside the patient’s body after surgery. This can lead to infection, internal bleeding, and other complications.


  • Miscounting Instruments: Failure to properly count surgical instruments before and after surgery to ensure all are accounted for.
  • Poor Communication: Breakdown in communication between surgical team members during instrument exchange.
  • Distractions in the OR: Unnecessary distractions that disrupt the surgical team’s focus and increase the risk of overlooking instruments.

Prevention Strategies:

Strategy Description
Instrument Checklists Utilizing standardized checklists to ensure all instruments are accounted for before, during, and after surgery.
Advanced Technology Employing radiofrequency tags or barcode tracking systems for surgical instruments.
Teamwork and Communication Encouraging clear communication and collaboration within the surgical team.

4. Postoperative Complications

Complications arise after surgery, potentially due to surgical errors or other factors. These can include:

  • Infections: Improper sterilization techniques prior to or during surgery can increase the risk of infections.
  • Blood Clots: Surgical procedures can increase the risk of blood clots, which can be life-threatening if they travel to the lungs (pulmonary embolism).

Prevention Strategies:

Strategy Description
Infection Control Protocols Hospitals adhere to strict infection control protocols to minimize the risk of surgical site infections.
Blood Clot Prophylaxis Physicians prescribe medications or compression stockings to prevent blood clot formation after surgery.
Open Communication Patients are encouraged to report any unusual symptoms or concerns to their doctor following surgery.

By understanding these specific types of surgical errors and their potential preventative measures, you can become a more informed and engaged patient, actively participating in your surgical journey and advocating for your safety.

Legal Issues and Your Rights After Surgery

Surgical errors can have serious consequences, and understanding the legal aspects can empower you to protect yourself. Here’s a breakdown of key points:

Medical Malpractice:

Medical malpractice happens when a healthcare professional, like a surgeon or anesthesiologist, fails to follow the expected standards of care, causing harm to the patient. In surgery, this could involve:

  • Performing a surgery without your informed consent.
  • Operating on the wrong body part or performing an incorrect procedure.
  • Leaving surgical instruments inside you.
  • Giving you the wrong anesthesia or not monitoring you properly during surgery.

Example: A surgeon mistakenly operates on your left knee instead of the right one due to a communication breakdown or incorrect marking. An anesthesiologist administers an incorrect medication dosage, leading to problems during surgery.

Your Rights as a Patient:

  • Informed Consent: You have the right to understand the risks and benefits of any surgery before agreeing to it. This includes:
    • The purpose and nature of the surgery
    • Other treatment options available
    • Potential risks and complications
    • The surgeon’s qualifications and experience
  • Quality Care: You can expect a certain standard of care from healthcare professionals involved in your surgery, including the surgeon, nurses, and anesthesiologist.

Reporting Errors and Accountability:

  • Reporting: If you believe you’ve been the victim of a surgical error, it’s vital to report the incident. You can contact the hospital administration, your state’s medical licensing board, or a healthcare attorney.
  • Accountability: Reporting errors helps hold healthcare professionals accountable and prevents similar incidents from happening to others. In some cases, legal action may be necessary to seek compensation for damages caused by medical malpractice.

Ethical Considerations in Healthcare:

The medical profession has a core ethical obligation to “do no harm” to patients. Surgical errors not only impact your physical health but can also cause significant emotional distress and financial burden. Hospitals and healthcare providers are responsible for implementing safeguards and protocols to minimize errors and ensure your safety throughout the surgical process.

Preventing Surgical Errors

While surgical errors can occur, there are steps healthcare institutions and patients can take to minimize risks and promote a safer surgical environment. Here, we explore some key preventative measures:

Training and Education:

  • Continuous Learning: Surgeons and other healthcare professionals should continuously update their knowledge and skills through ongoing training and education programs. This ensures they stay current with best practices and advancements in surgical techniques.
  • Team-Based Training: Surgical teams, including surgeons, nurses, and anesthesiologists, should participate in training exercises emphasizing communication, teamwork, and anticipating potential challenges during surgery.

Communication and Teamwork:

Establishing clear communication protocols within the surgical team is important. This includes briefings before surgery, ensuring everyone knows the plan, and encouraging open communication throughout the procedure to identify and address concerns.

A well-functioning surgical team is like a well-oiled machine. Encouraging collaboration and fostering a culture of mutual respect empowers all team members to speak up if they see something that could compromise patient safety.

Checklists and Protocols:

  • Surgical Safety Checklists: Implementing standardized surgical safety checklists before, during, and after surgery has significantly reduced errors. These checklists ensure critical steps are not missed and promote clear communication within the surgical team.
  • Standardized Protocols: Hospitals adopting standardized protocols for procedures, equipment use, and medication administration can minimize the risk of errors. These protocols should be readily available and easily accessible to all surgical staff.

By prioritizing ongoing education, fostering clear communication, and implementing safety protocols, healthcare institutions can create a culture of safety that prioritizes patient well-being and minimizes the risk of surgical errors.

When to Seek Legal Guidance

If you suspect you or a loved one has been the victim of a surgical error, it’s imperative that you seek legal advice. The experienced medical malpractice attorneys at BIKLAW understand the complexities of these cases and are dedicated to fighting for your rights and the compensation you deserve.

Surgical practices constantly evolve, and a commitment to ongoing learning and improvement is paramount. Patients, healthcare professionals, and hospitals can create a safer surgical environment by working together.

Additional Resources:

Your informed participation is vital in ensuring a safe surgical experience. You can take control of your healthcare journey by advocating for yourself and understanding the potential risks. If you have any concerns about a potential surgical error, BIKLAW stands ready to be your strong legal advocate.

Questions? Contact us